Photos by Stacie Joy
Allan Dabrio Marrero stood beside his husband, Matthew, inside Middle Collegiate Church this afternoon, thanking him for "not allowing me to give up on myself" during an emotional homecoming after nearly five months in ICE detention.
"I want to thank my husband Matthew for not allowing me to give up on myself — thank you, I love you," Allan told the audience.
Allan had been detained on Nov. 24, 2025, during a routine green card interview at 26 Federal Plaza.
According to media accounts, the couple learned there that a removal order had been issued for Allan in 2022, based on a notice he missed while he was between addresses. The Department of Homeland Security said the order stemmed from his overstaying a tourist visa years earlier.
But Allan, who is from the Cayman Islands, had already begun an asylum process before that visa expired. He and Matthew have been married for 10 years.
Marrero, who has no criminal record, was held at five facilities over the past six months, including the infamous "Alligator Alcatraz" in Florida.
His case drew support from advocates and local organizations, including Middle Collegiate Church, where the two are parishioners here on Seventh Street between First Avenue and Second Avenue.
In January, a judge granted Allan release on bond, but he remained in ICE custody for months afterward.
"ICE refused to accept the bond payment," Alexandra Rizio, supervising immigration attorney for Make the Road New York, said today. "Despite the judge's order, he was not released."
"They purposely, I feel, do that to you for the fact of mentally trying to break you down into signing a self-deportation," Allen said. "'Alligator Alcatraz' was by far the worst."
Today's press conference featured Public Advocate Jumaane D. Williams, the Rev. Dr. Jacqui Lewis, senior minister of Middle Collegiate (below), and other local elected officials.
Said Williams: "Allan Dabrio Marrero is free — and it was so moving to welcome him home. But it's bittersweet. It shouldn't take around-the-clock work to keep one of our neighbors from being jailed illegally. We're going to use this pain to free others and prevent wrongful detention in the first place."
In an Instagram post, Lewis wrote: "Today we celebrate. Tomorrow we fight with love."














































